Are You Voting For The Non-Sequiter Party?

8 08 2008

American politics is the stupid arguments of two stupid parties. One party’s arguments make terrible sense, and the other party’s arguments make no sense of all (the non-sequiter party). Here’s a good example of the latter:

One thing has been driving me crazy about this drilling debate — everyone seems to assume that if we drill for oil in the US, that we will get the oil. And hence, we won’t be dependent on foreign oil anymore. But we won’t get anything, Exxon-Mobil will.

The oil that comes from that drilling will not be United States property (Republicans aren’t suggesting we nationalize the oil companies, are they?). It will be the property of whichever oil company got the rights to that contract. They can then sell it to whoever they like — and they will. They will sell it on the world market, so the Chinese will have just as much access to the oil that comes out of the coast of Florida as we will.

The Democrats have done a decent job of beating back the argument that this will effect prices in the short run, or even in the long run. But no one has addressed the point above. The Republicans make it seem like we won’t be dependent on foreign oil — and that prices will go down in the US — if we have our own oil. But it won’t be ours. And it will be sold on the world market, so its effect on global oil prices will be even smaller.

When we ask the question of whether there should be drilling off the coast of Florida or in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, we should ask the question this way — would you be comfortable with the Chinese or the Germans or Russians or the Saudis drilling on American land? Because for all intents and purposes, they will be.

Large multi-national firms like Exxon-Mobil are not US property. They sell to the world and their allegiance is to corporate profits. So, when they drill, they drill for the whole world, not just us. Some might find that heart-warming, but it certainly has nothing to do with the US having more oil or lower prices.

What’s bizarre is that candidates fashion a “platform” out of these arguments that make no sense at all, but with a suit and tie and Lee Greenwood playing in the background, it sure sounds good.

Well, enough critical thinking for one night. You may return to your beer and ballgames now.




3 responses

9 08 2008
Boyd Livingstone

Well, I was going to vote for Dems for offering the vouchers for the magic TV box. Now that my living room is sporting a large screen TV thanks to the economic stimulus check, I am not sure where to place my loyalty.

I think I’ll wait to see which candidate pledges to make the oil companies pay the gasoline tax. That should fix the credit crisis.

Now, if you could quiet down over there, for the Olympics have just started.

9 08 2008
Scott Terry

That letter nails whats what has bothered me about this whole debate. When I bring this up to Stupid Party loyalists they just stand there with a…..well…stupid look on their faces. God help us!

15 08 2008
Earth To Chuck Baldwin! « Floyd’s

[…] The 800-pound gorilla here is this – Who is this “WE“? Typical conservative non-sequiter campaign garbage. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: